Supramolecular Synthons in Protein-Ligand Frameworks.

Supramolecular synthons, defined as reproducible intermolecular structural units, have greatly aided small molecule crystal engineering. In this paper, we propose that supramolecular synthons guide ligand-mediated protein crystallization. The protein RSL and the macrocycle sulfonato-calix[8]arene cocrystallize in at least four ways. One of these cocrystals is a highly porous cube comprising protein nodes connected by calixarene dimers. We show that mutating an aspartic acid to an asparagine results in two new cubic assemblies that depend also on the crystallization method. One of the new cubic arrangements is mediated by calixarene trimers and has a ∼30% increased cell volume relative to the original crystal with calixarene dimers. Crystals of the sulfonato-calix[8]arene sodium salt were obtained from buffered conditions similar to those used to grow the protein-calix[8]arene cocrystals. X-ray analysis reveals a coordination polymer of the anionic calix[8]arene and sodium cation in which the macrocycle is arranged as staggered stacks of the pleated loop conformation. Remarkably, the calixarene packing arrangement is the same in the simple salt as in the protein cocrystal. With the pleated loop conformation, the calixarene presents an extended surface for binding other calixarenes (oligomerization) as well as binding to a protein patch (biomolecular complexation). Small-angle X-ray scattering data suggest pH-dependent calixarene assembly in solution. Therefore, the calix[8]arene-calix[8]arene structural unit may be regarded as a supramolecular synthon that directs at least two types of protein assembly, suggesting applications in protein crystal engineering.

Multivalent Calixarene Complexation of a Designed Pentameric Lectin.

We describe complex formation between a designed pentameric ß-propeller and the anionic macrocycle sulfonato-calix[8]arene (sclx8), as characterized by X-ray crystallography and NMR spectroscopy. Two crystal structures and 15N HSQC experiments reveal a single calixarene binding site in the concave pocket of the ß-propeller toroid. Despite the symmetry mismatch between the pentameric protein and the octameric macrocycle, they form a high affinity multivalent complex, with the largest protein-calixarene interface observed to date. This system provides a platform for investigating multivalency.

Protein-macrocycle polymorphism: crystal form IV of the Ralstonia solanacearum lectin-sulfonato-calix[8]arene complex.

Controlled protein assembly and crystallization is necessary as a means of generating diffraction-quality crystals as well as providing a basis for new types of biomaterials. Water-soluble calixarenes are useful mediators of protein crystallization. Recently, it was demonstrated that Ralstonia solanacearum lectin (RSL) co-crystallizes with anionic sulfonato-calix[8]arene (sclx8) in three space groups. Two of these co-crystals only grow at pH ≤ 4 where the protein is cationic, and the crystal packing is dominated by the calixarene. This paper describes a fourth RSL-sclx8 co-crystal, which was discovered while working with a cation-enriched mutant. Crystal form IV grows at high ionic strength in the pH range 5-6. While possessing some features in common with the previous forms, the new structure reveals alternative calixarene binding modes. The occurrence of C2-symmetric assemblies, with the calixarene at special positions, appears to be an important result for framework fabrication. Questions arise regarding crystal screening and exhaustive searching for polymorphs.

Cage versus sheet: Probing the Determinants of Protein - Cucurbit[7]uril Crystalline Architectures.

The donut-shaped cucurbit[n]urils (Qn) are a class of rigid macrocyclic receptor with protein recognition capabilities. Qn encapsulation of amino acid side chains can enable protein assembly. Recently, cucurbit[7]uril (Q7) has been applied as a molecular glue for organizing protein building blocks into crystalline architectures. Q7 co-crystallization with dimethylated Ralstonia solanacearum lectin (RSL*) has yielded novel crystalline architectures. Co-crystallization of RSL* and Q7 yields either cage- or sheet-like architectures which may be modulated via protein engineering. However, questions remain as to the factors dictating the formation of one architecture over another (cage versus sheet). Here, we make use of an engineered RSL*-Q7 system which co-crystallizes as the cage or sheet assembly with easily-distinguished crystal morphologies. Using this model system, we probe how the crystallization conditions dictate which crystalline architecture is adopted. Protein-ligand ratios and the sodium concentration were identified as key determinants for the growth of the cage versus sheet assemblies.

Where is the Macrocycle? Comment on "Simultaneous Organic and Inorganic Host-Guest Chemistry within Pillararene-Protein Cage Frameworks."

Kostiainen and co-workers claim to have prepared crystals of ferritin by "electrostatically bridging" the protein with a cationic pillar[5]arene. Questions remain regarding the contribution of the pillar[5]arene to protein assembly and the putative role as a molecular glue.

Solid-state NMR - a complementary technique for protein framework characterization.

Protein frameworks are an emerging class of biomaterial with medical and technological applications. Frameworks are studied mainly by X-ray diffraction or scattering techniques. Complementary strategies are required. Here, we report solid-state NMR analyses of a microcrystalline protein-macrocycle framework and the rehydrated freeze-dried protein. This methodology may aid the characterization of low-crystallinity frameworks.

Molecular characterization of accripin11, a soluble shell protein with an acidic C-terminus, identified in the prismatic layer of the Mediterranean fan mussel Pinna nobilis (Bivalvia, Pteriomorphia).

We have identified a novel shell protein, accripin11, as a major soluble component of the calcitic prisms of the fan mussel Pinna nobilis. Initially retrieved from a cDNA library, its full sequence is confirmed here by transcriptomic and proteomic approaches. The sequence of the mature protein is 103 residues with a theoretical molecular weight of 11 kDa and is moderately acidic (pI 6.74) except for its C-terminus which is highly enriched in aspartic acid. The protein exhibits a peculiar cysteine pattern in its central domain. The full sequence shares similarity with six other uncharacterized molluscan shell proteins from the orders Ostreida, Pteriida and Mytilida, all of which are pteriomorphids and produce a phylogenetically restricted pattern of nacro-prismatic shell microstructures. This suggests that accripin11 is a member of a family of clade-specific shell proteins. A 3D model of accripin11 was predicted with AlphaFold2, indicating that it possesses three short alpha helices and a disordered C-terminus. Recombinant accripin11 was tested in vitro for its ability to influence the crystallization of CaCO3 , while a polyclonal antibody was able to locate accripin11 to prismatic extracts, particularly in the acetic acid-soluble matrix. The putative functions of accripin11 are further discussed in relation to shell biomineralization.

Complex Formation between Cytochrome c and a Tetra-alanino-calix[4]arene.

Owing to their remarkable features, calix[n]arenes are being exploited to study different aspects of molecular recognition, including protein complexation. Different complexation modes have been described, depending on the moieties that complement the aromatic cavity, allowing for function regulation and/or controlled assembly of the protein target. Here, a rigid cone calix[4]arene, bearing four anionic alanine units at the upper rim, was tested as a ligand for cytochrome c. Cocrystallization attempts were unfruitful, preventing a solid-state study of the system. Next, the complex was studied using NMR spectroscopy, which revealed the presence of two binding sites at lysine residues with dissociation constants (Kd) in the millimolar range.

Protein-Calixarene Complexation: From Recognition to Assembly.

This Account summarizes the progress in protein-calixarene complexation, tracing the developments from binary recognition to the glue activity of calixarenes and beyond to macrocycle-mediated frameworks. During the past 10 years, we have been tackling the question of protein-calixarene complexation in several ways, mainly by cocrystallization and X-ray structure determination as well as by solution state methods, NMR spectroscopy, isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), and light scattering. Much of this work benefitted from collaboration, highlighted here. Our first breakthrough was the cocrystallization of cationic cytochrome c with sulfonato-calix[4]arene leading to a crystal structure defining three binding sites. Together with NMR studies, a dynamic complexation was deduced in which the calixarene explores the protein surface. Other cationic proteins were similarly amenable to cocrystallization with sulfonato-calix[4]arene, confirming calixarene-arginine/lysine encapsulation and consequent protein assembly. Calixarenes bearing anionic substituents such as sulfonate or phosphonate, but not carboxylate, have proven useful.Studies with larger calix[n]arenes (n = 6, 8) demonstrated the bigger better binder phenomenon with increased affinities and more interesting assemblies, including solution-state oligomerization and porous frameworks. While the calix[4]arene cavity accommodates a single cationic side chain, the larger macrocycles adopt different conformations, molding to the protein surface and accommodating several residues (hydrophobic, polar, and/or charged) in small cavities. In addition to accommodating protein features, the calixarene can bind exogenous components such as polyethylene glycol (PEG), metal ions, buffer, and additives. Ternary cocrystallization of cytochrome c, sulfonato-calix[8]arene, and spermine resulted in altered framework fabrication due to calixarene encapsulation of the tetraamine. Besides host-guest chemistry with exogenous components, the calixarene can also self-assemble, with numerous instances of macrocycle dimers.Calixarene complexation enables protein encapsulation, not merely side chain encapsulation. Cocrystal structures of sulfonato-calix[8]arene with cytochrome c or Ralstonia solanacearum lectin (RSL) provide evidence of encapsulation, with multiple calixarenes masking the same protein. NMR studies of cytochrome c and sulfonato-calix[8]arene are also consistent with multisite binding. In the case of RSL, a C3 symmetric trimer, up to six calixarenes bind the protein yielding a cubic framework mediated by calixarene dimers. Biomolecular calixarene complexation has evolved from molecular recognition to framework construction. This latter development contributes to the challenge in design and preparation of porous molecular materials. Cytochrome c and sulfonato-calix[8]arene form frameworks with >60% solvent in which the degree of porosity depends on the protein:calixarene ratio and the crystallization conditions. Recent developments with RSL led to three frameworks with varying porosity depending on the crystallization conditions, particularly the pH. NMR studies indicate a pH-triggered assembly in which two acidic residues appear to play key roles. The field of supramolecular protein chemistry is growing, and this Account aims to encourage new developments at the interface between biomolecular and synthetic/supramolecular chemistry.

Protein Frameworks with Thiacalixarene and Zinc.

Controlled protein assembly provides a means to generate biomaterials. Synthetic macrocycles such as the water-soluble sulfonato-calix[n]arenes are useful mediators of protein assembly. Sulfonato-thiacalix[4]arene (tsclx 4 ), with its metal-binding capacity, affords the potential for simultaneous macrocycle- and metal-mediated protein assembly. Here, we describe the tsclx 4 -/Zn-directed assembly of two proteins: cationic α-helical cytochrome c (cyt c) and neutral ß-propeller Ralstonia solanacearum lectin (RSL). Two co-crystal forms were obtained with cyt c, each involving multinuclear zinc sites supported by the cone conformation of tsclx 4 . The tsclx 4 /Zn cluster acted as an assembly node via both lysine encapsulation and metal-mediated protein-protein contacts. In the case of RSL, tsclx 4 adopted the 1,2-alternate conformation and supported a dinuclear zinc site with concomitant encapsulation and metal-binding of two histidine side chains. These results, together with the knowledge of thiacalixarene/metal nanoclusters, suggest promising applications for thiacalixarenes in biomaterials and MOF fabrication.

Segregated Protein-Cucurbit[7]uril Crystalline Architectures via Modulatory Peptide Tectons.

One approach to protein assembly involves water-soluble supramolecular receptors that act like glues. Bionanoarchitectures directed by these scaffolds are often system-specific, with few studies investigating their customization. Herein, the modulation of cucurbituril-mediated protein assemblies through the inclusion of peptide tectons is described. Three peptides of varying length and structural order were N-terminally appended to RSL, a ß-propeller building block. Each fusion protein was incorporated into crystalline architectures mediated by cucurbit[7]uril (Q7). A trimeric coiled-coil served as a spacer within a Q7-directed sheet assembly of RSL, giving rise to a layered material of varying porosity. Within the spacer layers, the coiled-coils were dynamic. This result prompted consideration of intrinsically disordered peptides (IDPs) as modulatory tectons. Similar to the coiled-coil, a mussel adhesion peptide (Mefp) also acted as a spacer between protein-Q7 sheets. In contrast, the fusion of a nucleoporin peptide (Nup) to RSL did not recapitulate the sheet assembly. Instead, a Q7-directed cage was adopted, within which disordered Nup peptides were partially "captured" by Q7 receptors. IDP capture occurred by macrocycle recognition of an intrapeptide Phe-Gly motif in which the benzyl group was encapsulated by Q7. The modularity of these protein-cucurbituril architectures adds a new dimension to macrocycle-mediated protein assembly. Segregated protein crystals, with alternating layers of high and low porosity, could provide a basis for new types of materials.

Noncovalent Protein-Pseudorotaxane Assembly Incorporating an Extended Arm Calix[8]arene with α-Helical Recognition Properties.

Water-soluble, anionic calix[n]arenes are useful receptors for protein recognition and assembly. For example, sulfonato-calix[8]arene (sclx 8 ) can encapsulate proteins and direct their assembly into porous frameworks. In this work, we turned our attention to an "extended arm" calixarene with 16 phenyl rings. We hypothesized that this larger receptor would have increased capacity for protein masking/encapsulation. A cocrystal structure of p-benzyl-sulfonato-calix[8]arene (b-sclx 8 ) and cytochrome c (cyt c) revealed a surprising assembly. A pseudorotaxane comprising a stack of three b-sclx 8 molecules threaded by polyethylene glycol (PEG) was bound to the protein. The trimeric b-sclx 8 stack, a tubelike structure with a highly charged surface, mediated assembly via a new mode of protein recognition. The calixarene stack presents four hydrophobic grooves, each of which binds to one cyt c by accommodating the N-terminal α-helix. This unprecedented binding mode suggests new possibilities for supramolecular protein chemistry.

Porous assembly of an antifungal protein mediated by zinc and sulfonato-calix[8]arene.

Controlled protein assembly holds great potential in the fabrication of biohybrid materials. However, the structural diversity and complexity of proteins present an obstacle to controlled assembly. Supramolecular chemistry is a possible solution as it offers tools to mediate self-assembly with molecular precision. This paper deals with the calixarene- and zinc-mediated assembly and crystallization of the histidine-rich Penicillium chrysogenum antifungal protein B (PAFB). We report crystal structures of pure PAFB, PAFB in complex with Zn2+, and the ternary complex of PAFB, Zn2+ and sulfonato-calix[8]arene (sclx8). A comparison of the three crystal structures revealed the structural plasticity of PAFB. While the flexible and highly anionic sclx8 resulted in large molecular weight aggregates of PAFB in solution, diffraction-quality crystals of PAFB-sclx8 were not obtained. We report crystals of PAFB-Zn2+-sclx8 in which a trinuclear zinc cluster occurred adjacent to a calixarene binding site. Interestingly, the combination of sclx8 complexation and zinc coordination resulted in a porous framework with channels of circa 2 nm diameter. Detailed analysis of the crystal structure highlighted novel molecular recognition features. This research enriches the set of supramolecular interactions available to promote protein assembly.

Facile Fabrication of Protein-Macrocycle Frameworks.

Precisely defined protein aggregates, as exemplified by crystals, have applications in functional materials. Consequently, engineered protein assembly is a rapidly growing field. Anionic calix[n]arenes are useful scaffolds that can mold to cationic proteins and induce oligomerization and assembly. Here, we describe protein-calixarene composites obtained via cocrystallization of commercially available sulfonato-calix[8]arene (sclx8) with the symmetric and "neutral" protein RSL. Cocrystallization occurred across a wide range of conditions and protein charge states, from pH 2.2-9.5, resulting in three crystal forms. Cationization of the protein surface at pH ∼ 4 drives calixarene complexation and yielded two types of porous frameworks with pore diameters >3 nm. Both types of framework provide evidence of protein encapsulation by the calixarene. Calixarene-masked proteins act as nodes within the frameworks, displaying octahedral-type coordination in one case. The other framework formed millimeter-scale crystals within hours, without the need for precipitants or specialized equipment. NMR experiments revealed macrocycle-modulated side chain pKa values and suggested a mechanism for pH-triggered assembly. The same low pH framework was generated at high pH with a permanently cationic arginine-enriched RSL variant. Finally, in addition to protein framework fabrication, sclx8 enables de novo structure determination.

Protein recognition by cucurbit[6]uril: high affinity N-terminal complexation.

The donut-shaped cucurbit[n]urils (Qn, n = 6-8) are rigid macrocyclic receptors with widespread use in protein recognition. To date, most applications have centred on the encapsulation of N-terminal aromatic residues by Q7 or Q8. Less attention has been placed on Q6, which can recognize lysine side chains due to its high affinity for alkylamines. In this work, we investigated protein-Q6 complexation by using NMR spectroscopy. Attempts to crystallize protein-Q6 complexes were thwarted by the crystallization of Q6. We studied four proteins that vary in size, net charge, and lysine content. In addition to Q6 interactions with specific Lys or dimethylated Lys residues, we report striking evidence for N-terminal recognition. High affinity (micromolar) binding occurred with the N-terminal Met-Lys motif present in one of the four model proteins. Engineering this feature into another model protein yielded a similar high affinity site. We also present evidence for Q8 binding at this N-terminal feature. These data expand the cucurbituril toolkit for protein sensing.

Engineered assembly of a protein-cucurbituril biohybrid.

A crystalline biohybrid with a 4 : 1 protein : cucurbituril mass ratio is presented. This result was achieved by engineering additional cucurbit[7]uril (Q7) binding sites into a ß-propeller protein. In contrast to the parent protein, Q7-controlled assembly of the engineered variant occurred in solution, as evidenced by NMR and SAXS measurements.

Probing the determinants of porosity in protein frameworks: co-crystals of cytochrome c and an octa-anionic calix[4]arene.

Sulfonato-calix[n]arenes (sclxn) are promising tools to generate crystalline protein frameworks. We report, for the first time, a lower rim functionalised octa-anionic calix[4]arene (sclx4mc) in complex with proteins. Two crystal structures of sclx4mc bound to yeast or horse heart cytochrome c (cytc) are described. Highly porous honeycomb or tubular assemblies were obtained with yeast or horse cytc, respectively. Related frameworks were obtained previously with sclx8 and sclx6 but not with sclx4, suggesting that the ligand charge is a determining factor.

Tuning Protein Frameworks via Auxiliary Supramolecular Interactions.

Protein crystals with their precise, periodic array of functional building blocks have potential applications in biomaterials, sensing, and catalysis. This paper describes how a highly porous crystalline framework of a cationic redox protein and an anionic macrocycle can be modulated by a small cationic effector. Ternary composites of protein (∼13 kDa), calix[8]arene (∼1.5 kDa), and effector (∼0.2 kDa) formed distinct crystalline architectures, dependent on the effector concentration and the crystallization technique. A combination of X-ray crystallography and density functional theory (DFT) calculations was used to decipher the framework variations, which appear to be dependent on a calixarene conformation change mediated by the effector. This "switch" calixarene was observed in three states, each of which is associated with a different interaction network. Two structures obtained by co-crystallization with the effector contained an additional protein "pillar", resulting in framework duplication and decreased porosity. These results suggest how protein assembly can be engineered by supramolecular host-guest interactions.

Crystal structure of a protein-aromatic foldamer composite: macromolecular chiral resolution.

Co-crystallization of a 2 kDa tether-free sulfonated foldamer and the 13 kDa lysine-rich cytochrome c yielded a remarkable biohybrid assembly with chiral resolution of the foldamer helix handedness. In the crystal a ∼5 nm foldamer stack was surrounded by eight molecules of protein. NMR and CD experiments suggest interesting differences in the solution state recognition processes.

Calixarene capture of partially unfolded cytochrome c.

Supramolecular receptors such as water-soluble calixarenes are in development as 'molecular glues' for protein assembly. Here, we obtained cocrystals of sulfonato-calix[6]arene (sclx6 ) and yeast cytochrome c (cytc) in the presence of imidazole. A crystal structure at 2.65 Å resolution reveals major structural rearrangement and disorder in imidazole-bound cytc. The largest protein-calixarene interface involves 440 Å2 of the protein surface with key contacts at Arg13, Lys73, and Lys79. These lysines participate in alkaline transitions of cytc and are part of Ω-loop D, which is substantially restructured in the complex with sclx6 . The structural modification also includes Ω-loop C, which is disordered (residues 41-55 inclusive). These results suggest the possibility of using supramolecular scaffolds to trap partially disordered proteins.